Home Depot vs. Lowe's: What's the Better Buy?

Core Viewpoint - Both Home Depot (HD) and Lowe's (LOW) have shown positive year-over-year comparable sales growth for the first time in eight periods, indicating a potential recovery in the home improvement market [3][4][17]. Group 1: Quarterly Results - Home Depot's comparable store sales increased by 0.8% year-over-year, with U.S. comparable sales rising by 1.3% [4]. - Lowe's comparable store sales rose by 0.2% year-over-year, surpassing the consensus estimate of a -1.4% decline [5][4]. - Both companies have reported their second consecutive positive readings on comparable sales, suggesting improving performance in existing locations [8][4]. Group 2: Valuation - Lowe's shares are trading at a lower forward 12-month earnings multiple compared to Home Depot, with a significantly lower PEG ratio [10]. - Lowe's is projected to achieve a 4.3% year-over-year EPS growth this fiscal year, while Home Depot is expected to see only 1.6% growth [10]. - Given the current PEG ratios, Lowe's valuation appears more attractive [10]. Group 3: Estimate Revisions - Analysts have revised EPS expectations more negatively for Home Depot compared to Lowe's following the latest earnings releases [12][16]. - The stability in Lowe's earnings picture is viewed positively, while the downward revisions for Home Depot raise concerns [16]. - Top line revisions for both companies' upcoming earnings reports have been marginally positive [16]. Group 4: Overall Outlook - Despite near-term uncertainties in the home improvement market, the positive change in comparable sales for both companies suggests potential momentum [17]. - Lowe's shares are currently considered the better investment based on valuation, forecasted EPS growth, and a more favorable earnings outlook following recent results [18].