Better Beaten-Down Stock to Buy: Pfizer Vs. Moderna

Core Insights - Pfizer and Moderna were the two leading companies in developing effective coronavirus vaccines, achieving significant financial success during the pandemic [1] - Both companies have experienced a substantial decline in revenue and share prices as the pandemic has receded, raising questions about their future performance [2] Pfizer - Pfizer has made strategic moves, including the approval of new medicines and vaccines, and a significant acquisition of Seagen for $43 billion, enhancing its oncology pipeline [3] - In 2024, Pfizer reported a revenue of$63.6 billion, a 7% increase from the previous year, with adjusted earnings per share of $3.11, reflecting a 69$11.1 billion in sales in 2024 [4] - Pfizer is expected to navigate upcoming patent cliffs successfully, supported by its ongoing product approvals and a strong dividend yield of 6.8%, with a 53.6% increase in payouts over the past decade [5][6] Moderna - Moderna's total revenue in 2024 fell nearly 53% year-over-year to $3.2 billion, with a net loss per share of$9.28, although this was an improvement from the previous year's loss [7] - The company has received approval for an RSV vaccine and is awaiting further label expansions, indicating potential growth opportunities [8] - Moderna's combination COVID/influenza vaccine showed promising results in a phase 3 study, and the company is pursuing multiple late-stage studies for innovative products, including a personalized cancer vaccine [9][10] - The mRNA platform has demonstrated success, and if Moderna continues to achieve positive clinical results and regulatory approvals, its financial performance may improve [10] Comparative Analysis - Pfizer is characterized as a well-established pharmaceutical giant with consistent revenue from a diverse product portfolio, while Moderna is a smaller biotech company with fewer profitable products [11] - Pfizer outperforms Moderna in key financial metrics such as total sales, profits, and free cash flow, and it also offers dividends, making it attractive for income-seeking investors [12] - While Pfizer is viewed as the better investment option for most investors, Moderna may present higher upside potential for those willing to accept greater risk and volatility [13]