PGR vs. ALL: Which Auto Insurer is a Safe Investment Bet?

Core Viewpoint - The recent tariffs imposed by President Trump, particularly the 25% tariffs on imported vehicles, are expected to increase car prices and insurance premiums, significantly impacting the auto insurance industry, especially companies like Progressive Corporation (PGR) and Allstate Corporation (ALL) [1]. Group 1: Progressive Corporation (PGR) - PGR is one of the largest auto insurance groups in the U.S., leading in motorcycle and boat policies, commercial auto insurance, and ranking among the top 15 homeowners carriers based on premiums written [3]. - The company has embraced digitalization and AI, with its Snapshot program offering customized pricing, leading to competitive rates and improved policy life expectancy (PLE) across all business lines [4]. - PGR's combined ratio has averaged less than 93% over the past decade, significantly better than the industry average of over 100%, supported by prudent underwriting and favorable reserve development [5]. - The net margin has shown continuous improvement, expanding by 980 basis points in the last two years due to rising demand for personal auto insurance and effective risk management [6]. - PGR's solid cash flow allows for ongoing investments in growth initiatives, including digitalization, while enhancing book value and reducing leverage [7]. - The company is focusing on expanding its offerings into homeowners and commercial insurance, with a return on equity of 33.8%, outperforming the industry average of 8.3% [8]. - The Zacks Consensus Estimate for PGR's 2025 revenue and EPS indicates a year-over-year increase of 16.1% and 9.8%, respectively, with EPS estimates trending upward [13]. Group 2: Allstate Corporation (ALL) - ALL is the third-largest property-casualty insurer and the largest publicly held personal lines carrier in the U.S., aiming to be a low-cost digital insurer with broad distribution capabilities [9]. - The company expects an increase in total Property-Liability policies in force this year, driven by improved auto insurance policy renewal rates and new business growth [9]. - ALL's net margin has improved by 980 basis points over the last two years, supported by prudent underwriting, although it faces challenges in maintaining its combined ratio target in the mid-90s for the auto business due to rising auto claims [10][11]. - The company is focused on reducing losses, which may lead to a decline in the number of policies in force, while facing inflationary pressures and escalating repair costs [11]. - ALL's return on equity stands at 28.2%, also better than the industry average [12]. - The Zacks Consensus Estimate for ALL's 2025 revenues and EPS implies a year-over-year increase of 2% and 7.9%, respectively, with EPS estimates also moving upward [14]. Group 3: Comparative Analysis - PGR is trading at a price-to-book multiple of 5.97X, above its five-year median of 4.65X, while ALL's price-to-book multiple is at 2.51X, also above its median of 1.9X [15]. - PGR has outperformed ALL in terms of share price growth, gaining 26.3% in the past year compared to ALL's 8.1% [18]. - Based on return on equity, PGR is considered a more efficient generator of profit from shareholders' equity compared to ALL, with PGR holding a Zacks Rank 2 (Buy) and ALL a Zacks Rank 3 (Hold) [18].