Core Viewpoint - Huaxi Biological (688363.SZ) criticizes certain brokerage reports for misleading the market regarding the hyaluronic acid (HA) industry, claiming that these reports promote the idea that HA is outdated and misrepresent its value compared to recombinant collagen [1][2][5] Group 1: Criticism of Brokerage Reports - Huaxi Biological specifically names brokerages such as Western Securities, Anxin Securities, and Xinda Securities, accusing them of publishing misleading conclusions that favor recombinant collagen over hyaluronic acid [1][2][4] - The company argues that these reports distort scientific facts and mislead consumers, damaging the trust in the Chinese biotechnology and medical aesthetics industry [1][6] - Huaxi Biological emphasizes the importance of maintaining a fair competitive environment and the integrity of scientific information in the industry [1][6] Group 2: Market Dynamics and Competition - The criticism from Huaxi Biological is seen as a response to the rising competition from Juzhi Biological (02367.HK), which focuses on recombinant collagen and has been gaining market traction [1][8][12] - Huaxi Biological's performance has been declining, with projected revenues and net profits for 2024 showing significant decreases compared to previous years, while Juzhi Biological has experienced substantial growth [10][12] - The company highlights that the narrative of HA being outdated is a construct of "restless capital" aiming to shift focus to new market trends, which undermines the established value of HA [13][14] Group 3: Industry Support and Response - Following Huaxi Biological's statements, two industry associations, the China Fragrance and Cosmetic Industry Association and the China Aesthetic Medicine Association, issued a joint initiative advocating for scientific integrity and ethical marketing practices [7] - Huaxi Biological reports that many institutions have retracted erroneous reports and some have issued apologies, indicating a recognition of the misleading nature of the previous analyses [6][12] - The company maintains ongoing communication with brokerage firms regarding the accuracy of research reports and their implications for the industry [6][12]