Better Buy Now: A 50/50 Split of Costco and Walmart or Dollar General and Dollar Tree?

Group 1 - Dollar General and Dollar Tree are experiencing significant recoveries in 2025, with Dollar General up 49.5% and Dollar Tree up 25.2% year to date, compared to a 2.1% gain in the S&P 500 [1][2] - Both companies had low expectations going into 2025 due to struggles with inflationary pressures and price increases [4][6] - Dollar Tree's decision to raise its base price to $1.25 in 2021 affected demand, and it is selling Family Dollar for about $1 billion, a significant loss compared to its $9 billion purchase price in 2015 [5][6] Group 2 - Dollar General's sales are increasing, but its margins are near a 10-year low due to pricing pressure, while Dollar Tree's revenue is down significantly due to store closures and demand pressures [7][9] - Despite mediocre results, the low expectations set the stage for a rebound in both stocks [10] - Walmart and Costco, while having thin margins, have successfully delivered value to customers, maintaining steady sales and decent margins [11][12] Group 3 - Walmart and Costco have higher valuations, with forward P/E ratios exceeding 20, while Dollar General and Dollar Tree have lower valuations under 20 [15][19] - Quality is more important than current valuation, as companies that consistently improve earnings can grow into their valuations [17] - Dollar General offers a dividend yield of 2.1%, while Dollar Tree has never paid a dividend, contrasting with Walmart's 0.9% and Costco's 0.5% yields [18] Group 4 - A 50/50 split of Dollar General and Dollar Tree is suggested over Walmart and Costco due to their lower valuations and slower growth rates of the latter [19][20] - Investing in high-quality companies is not advisable if their valuations are excessively high, especially when faster-growing alternatives are available at reasonable multiples [20]