ET vs. KMI: Which Midstream Stock Offers Investors Better Returns?

Industry Overview - The Zacks Oil and Gas Production and Pipeline industry is essential for meeting global energy demand, driven by economic growth and rising consumption in emerging markets [1] - Despite the shift toward renewables, hydrocarbons remain crucial for transportation, heating, and petrochemical production [1] - Technological advancements like horizontal drilling and enhanced recovery techniques are unlocking new reserves and boosting productivity [1] Pipeline Infrastructure - Pipeline infrastructure is critical for transporting crude oil, natural gas, and refined products efficiently [2] - Stable, fee-based revenue models and long-term contracts provide predictable cash flows for pipeline operators, insulating them from commodity price volatility [2] - The expansion of North American shale production and rising export capacity is expected to increase demand for midstream infrastructure [2] Company Comparisons - Energy Transfer (ET) and Kinder Morgan (KMI) are two of the largest midstream energy companies in North America, operating extensive networks of pipelines and storage facilities [3] - ET offers a diversified midstream infrastructure with stable cash flows and strategic export terminal access, positioning it well for rising U.S. energy production and global demand [4] - KMI has a primarily natural gas-focused midstream network with long-term contracts that provide predictable cash flows, appealing to income-focused investors [5] Earnings Growth Projections - The Zacks Consensus Estimate for ET's earnings per share (EPS) in 2025 and 2026 has increased by 2.86% and 4.26%, respectively [7] - KMI's 2025 EPS estimate has declined by 0.8%, while its 2026 EPS moved up by 2.26% [9] Dividend Yield - ET offers a dividend yield of 7.2%, significantly higher than KMI's 4.04% and the S&P 500's average of 1.58% [8][12] Valuation Metrics - ET is trading at a forward P/E of 12.54X, which is cheaper than KMI's 22.08X and the S&P 500's 22.43X [8][15] - ET's current return on equity (ROE) is 11.47%, while KMI's ROE is 16.6%, both underperforming the S&P 500's ROE of 17.02% [10] Debt to Capital - ET's debt-to-capital ratio is 56.6%, compared to KMI's 48.42%, both higher than the S&P 500's 38.07% [14] Price Performance - ET's units have gained 4.2% in the past month, outperforming KMI's 1.2% gain and the S&P 500's return of 4.4% [16] Conclusion - Energy Transfer is currently favored over Kinder Morgan due to rising earnings estimates, higher dividend yield, better return on equity, and cheaper valuation [20][21]