The Motley Foolยท2025-07-12 08:16Core Viewpoint - AGNC Investment offers a high monthly dividend yield exceeding 15%, significantly higher than the S&P 500, but has not increased its dividend in over 15 years and has cut it several times, making it less ideal for passive income seekers [1][13] Group 1: AGNC Investment - AGNC Investment focuses solely on mortgage-backed securities (MBS) that are protected from credit risk by government agencies, resulting in low returns [5] - The company enhances its returns by investing in MBS on a leveraged basis, which increases its risk profile [5] - Since its IPO in mid-2008, AGNC has cut its dividend several times, leading to a 50% loss in stock value since its IPO, despite a total return of over 10% annually [9][11] Group 2: Main Street Capital - Main Street Capital is a business development company (BDC) that provides capital solutions to lower middle market companies and has a higher risk profile but offers much higher returns, with a weighted average effective yield of 12.7% [6] - The company has never cut its monthly dividend since its IPO in 2007 and has increased its payout by 132% over the years, also providing supplemental dividends since 2013 [8] - Main Street Capital's stock price has increased nearly 10% annually, contributing to higher total returns compared to AGNC [11][12] Group 3: Comparison and Investment Considerations - While AGNC offers a substantial monthly dividend, its lack of growth in payouts and potential for future cuts may lead to lower long-term total returns [13] - In contrast, Main Street Capital provides an attractive and growing monthly dividend, supplemented by quarterly payouts, making it a potentially better long-term option for passive income [14]