Xin Lang Zheng Quan·2025-07-24 10:21Core Insights - The launch of the game "Mingmo: Yuanshu Zhi Yu" has been met with overwhelmingly negative reviews, with a player approval rate of only 19% based on 2,692 reviews on Steam, indicating significant dissatisfaction among players [1] - The game's failure is attributed to a combination of technical issues, trust erosion, and poor content positioning, leading to a catastrophic reception [2] Technical Issues - The game suffers from severe optimization problems, with high-end graphics cards like the RTX 4090 struggling to run the game at low resolutions, and common issues such as controller compatibility failures and missing key features [2][3] - The development team lacks the necessary technical foundation to effectively utilize the Unreal Engine 5, resulting in a subpar gaming experience [3][5] Trust Erosion - The release strategy was flawed, with permanent price reductions in certain regions on launch day, undermining player trust [2][5] - Operational mishaps, such as standard edition players receiving deluxe edition rewards, further damaged the credibility of the game's release [2][5] Content Positioning - The game attempts to merge the brutal history of the Ming Dynasty with Cthulhu mythology but ends up with a disjointed narrative that fails to resonate with players [2][4] - Historical events and figures are poorly represented, leading to accusations of historical distortion, which alienates history enthusiasts [2][4] Industry Reflection - The failure of "Mingmo" highlights the challenges faced by domestic AAA game developers, particularly in terms of technical capabilities and industrial maturity [3][5] - The contrasting success of "Black Myth: Wukong," which has a solid technical foundation and clear cultural expression, serves as a benchmark for future projects [5][6] Market Positioning - "Black Myth: Wukong" has a clear target of presenting Chinese stories with top-tier production standards, while "Mingmo" suffers from a lack of clear direction and technical ambition [6] - The industry must recognize that the "domestic" label is shifting from emotional support to a standard of scrutiny, with players expecting adherence to international quality benchmarks [7] Path Forward - For "Mingmo," immediate actions such as releasing significant optimization patches and addressing operational issues are crucial for rebuilding trust [7] - Smaller teams in the industry should focus on their strengths and explore differentiated niches rather than blindly pursuing AAA standards [7]