Is Advance Auto Parts a Buy?

Core Viewpoint - Advance Auto Parts is undergoing a turnaround plan, showing some positive signs despite facing significant competition and operational challenges [2][4][11]. Financial Performance - In Q1 2025, Advance Auto Parts reported net sales of $2.6 billion, a 7% decline, but exceeded its own guidance by approximately $80 million [4]. - The adjusted diluted earnings per share (EPS) was a loss of $0.22, surpassing the consensus estimate by $0.47 [4]. - The stock price increased by 57% following the Q1 results announcement [4]. Turnaround Strategy - The company aims to achieve positive operating margins by Q2, with guidance for adjusted operating income margin between 2.8% and 3% [5]. - Advance Auto Parts is consolidating its distribution network from 38 centers to 12 larger facilities to improve efficiency [11]. - The company has closed over 500 corporate stores and is expanding its network of "market hubs" to enhance parts availability and delivery speed [12]. Competitive Landscape - Advance Auto Parts has struggled with operational inefficiencies compared to competitors like AutoZone and O'Reilly Auto Parts, particularly in merchandising margins [7][8]. - The company is conducting line reviews with suppliers to improve profitability per part sold [8]. Market Response - Prior to a recent stock pullback, the share price had doubled from May 21 to July 21 [14]. - The forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is 30, which is a premium compared to its median P/E over the past decade but at the midpoint relative to competitors [15][17]. Future Outlook - Investors are looking for further signs of progress in the restructuring plan when the company reports Q2 results on August 14 [19]. - The company has seen a 1% increase in comparable-store sales in areas with operational improvements from market hubs [13].