Xin Lang Cai Jing·2025-08-04 23:37Core Viewpoint - The collision test between an 8-ton truck and the Li Auto i8 SUV has sparked controversy regarding its validity and the implications for automotive safety testing standards [1][3][5] Group 1: Collision Test Controversy - The test is criticized for being a non-standard vehicle-to-vehicle collision test, which does not evaluate the safety performance of other truck brands [1][3] - Concerns have been raised about the authenticity of the test scenario and the independence of the third-party testing agency [5][7] - The use of an empty truck (8 tons) in the test contrasts with the typical loaded weight of 20 tons or more in real accidents, raising questions about the energy differences in collision scenarios [5] Group 2: Statements from Involved Parties - China Automotive Technology and Research Center (CATARC) clarified that the test was solely to verify the safety of the Li Auto i8 and not to assess other brands [1][7] - Li Auto stated that the truck was merely a "mobile barrier" and that they did not intend to make quality assessments of the truck brand involved [3] - The truck manufacturer, Dongfeng Liuzhou Motor Co., emphasized that the test conditions were significantly different from real traffic situations [5] Group 3: Financial Performance of Testing Agency - CATARC reported a revenue of 4.697 billion yuan in 2023, a 14.65% increase year-on-year, with a profit of 1.14 billion yuan, also up 14% [8] - The automotive technology services segment contributed the most to revenue, generating 4.125 billion yuan, a 21.36% increase, with a gross margin of nearly 50% [9] - The revenue from new energy and intelligent connected vehicle development and testing grew by 42.86%, although its gross margin slightly decreased to 47.61% [9] Group 4: Industry Insights and Testing Practices - The automotive testing industry is under scrutiny for potentially prioritizing visually impactful test scenarios over rigorous safety evaluations [13][14] - Traditional collision tests are still conducted, but there is a growing trend for more sensational testing methods to attract consumer attention [13] - The automotive testing process involves multiple stages, including enterprise-commissioned tests and government approvals, ensuring that vehicles meet safety standards before market entry [11][12]