Home Depot vs. Lowe's: Which Home Improvement Stock Has Better Upside?

Core Insights - Home Depot and Lowe's are the leading companies in the U.S. home improvement retail sector, each pursuing different strategies in a challenging market characterized by high interest rates and selective consumer spending [1][2] Home Depot (HD) - Home Depot is focusing on leveraging its scale, supply-chain strength, and relationships with Pro customers to maintain market share [1] - The acquisition of SRS Distribution enhances Home Depot's Pro segment by adding complementary verticals and improving its trade credit program, which is vital for attracting large-scale Pro clients [3] - Investment in technology has improved delivery speed and customer engagement through an interconnected retail model, with AI tools enhancing store operations [4] - Home Depot's supply-chain diversification strategy reduces reliance on any single country, with over half of purchases sourced domestically, mitigating geopolitical risks [5] - Challenges include rising costs affecting margins, soft demand for big-ticket remodels due to high interest rates, and increased inventory levels [6] Lowe's (LOW) - Lowe's is strengthening its position in the Pro customer segment, with Pro sales increasing in the mid-single digits, supported by the MyLowe's Pro Rewards program [7] - The acquisition of Artisan Design Group positions Lowe's to tap into a fragmented $50 billion market and address the demand for new homes in the U.S. [8] - Lowe's is pursuing growth initiatives such as rural market expansion and new store openings, focusing on Pro sales and online growth through technology investments [9] - Online sales increased by 6% year-over-year, driven by higher traffic and improved conversion rates, with the launch of a home improvement product marketplace expanding offerings [10] - Operational efficiency initiatives have improved gross margins, but softness in big-ticket DIY categories remains a challenge, with comparable sales down 1.7% in the first quarter [11][12] Comparative Analysis - Home Depot's fiscal 2025 sales and EPS estimates suggest year-over-year growth of 3.1% and a decline of 1.4%, respectively [13] - Lowe's fiscal 2025 sales and EPS estimates indicate growth of 0.8% and 2.4%, respectively [14] - Home Depot's stock has gained 12.2% over the past year, outperforming Lowe's, which has risen 4.4% [16] - Home Depot trades at a forward price-to-sales (P/S) multiple of 2.29, while Lowe's is at 1.57, indicating Home Depot is priced higher [18] - The competitive edge currently favors Home Depot due to its scale, Pro relationships, and strategic acquisitions, while Lowe's faces challenges from macro-sensitive DIY categories and tariff risks [20]