高铁去泡面化：气味之争还是利益之争？

Core Viewpoint - The recent ban on instant noodles in high-speed train stations in Guangzhou and Shanghai reflects a broader trend towards enhancing the dining experience and maintaining cleanliness in train environments, but it has sparked significant public debate regarding the implications for affordability and passenger comfort [1][3][5]. Group 1: Policy Changes - Guangzhou East Station and other high-speed train stations have stopped selling instant noodles, replacing them with alternatives like mixed noodles and tossed noodles, following guidelines from the National Railway Group [1][3]. - The rationale behind this policy is to improve the overall service quality and environment of high-speed trains, as instant noodles are considered to potentially disrupt the cleanliness of enclosed train spaces [1][3]. Group 2: Public Reaction - Public opinion is divided; some support the ban, arguing that the strong smell of instant noodles can affect the comfort of other passengers in the shared space of a train [3][5]. - Critics argue that the ban is selective, pointing out that other strong-smelling snacks like durian and stinky tofu are still available, raising questions about the consistency of enforcement [3][5]. Group 3: Economic Considerations - The ban on instant noodles is seen as part of a larger issue regarding food pricing on high-speed trains, where meals can cost significantly more than instant noodles, making them less accessible for budget-conscious travelers [5][7]. - Many passengers, particularly students and workers, view instant noodles as an affordable option for long journeys, contrasting with the higher-priced meals offered on trains [5][7]. Group 4: Suggestions for Improvement - Suggestions have been made to create designated eating areas with ventilation to address the smell issue while still allowing passengers to enjoy affordable food options [7]. - The emphasis is on improving service quality and offering a wider range of reasonably priced food options to meet the needs of all passengers, rather than solely focusing on eliminating instant noodles [7].