ZACKSยท2025-08-18 20:55Core Insights - Target (TGT) and Walmart (WMT) are both major retail stocks trading near $100, but they are experiencing different market dynamics, with Walmart at a 52-week high and Target over 35% below its peak [1][2] Q2 Expectations - Target's Q2 sales are projected to decline by 2% to $24.91 billion compared to $25.45 billion a year ago, with earnings expected to fall approximately 20% to $2.06 per share from $2.57 in the prior year [3] - Walmart's Q2 sales are anticipated to increase by more than 3% to $175.51 billion from $169.34 billion in the previous period, with EPS expected to rise by 9% to $0.73 from $0.67 [4] Stock Performance Overview - Walmart's core business, particularly in grocery and essential items, is thriving, contributing nearly 60% of its sales, while Target is more exposed to discretionary categories that are struggling [5][6] - Walmart's stock has gained 11% this year, outperforming the broader market and Amazon, while Target's shares have declined by 22% [7] Valuation Comparison - Target's stock is trading at 13.7X forward earnings, significantly lower than Walmart's 38.4X and the S&P 500's 24.6X, indicating a more appealing valuation despite Walmart's competitive advantage [9] - Target's valuation is also below its decade-long high of 30.4X forward earnings and its median of 15.7X, while Walmart is near its decade peaks [10] Dividend Comparison - Both companies are recognized as Dividend Kings, but Target offers a more attractive annual dividend yield of 4.43%, compared to Walmart's 0.94% and the S&P 500's average of 1.15% [12] Conclusion & Final Thoughts - Long-term investors may find Target's stock appealing due to its valuation, while Walmart's near-term outlook justifies a premium for its stock [14] - The investment decision hinges on whether investors prefer Target's long-term value or Walmart's growth and defensive safety in the current market [15]