Why Rate Cuts May Not Put the Fizz Back in Pepsi's Stock

Core Viewpoint - PepsiCo Inc. has faced significant stock pressure, with a decline of 5.89% in 2025 and 19.5% over the last 12 months, reflecting broader challenges in the consumer staples sector [1][2] Group 1: Stock Performance and Market Context - The total return for PepsiCo stock over the last three years is negative 9.1%, indicating a decline in overall stock value despite a growing dividend yield of 4.02% [4] - Rising inflation and interest rates have pressured the core consumer, contributing to the stock's weak performance [5] - The consumer staples sector, including PepsiCo, has been under pressure for several years, complicating the narrative around interest rate cuts potentially benefiting the stock [2][9] Group 2: Demand Challenges and Competitive Landscape - The adoption of GLP-1 drugs is impacting consumer demand for soft drinks and salty snacks, posing a challenge to PepsiCo's traditional strengths [3] - Consumers are increasingly opting for store brands due to lower prices, which further pressures PepsiCo's market position [6] Group 3: Earnings and Strategic Pressure - PepsiCo's earnings per share (EPS) for the first two quarters were $3.6, down 7% year over year, raising concerns among investors [7] - Elliott Investment Management has taken a $4 billion stake in PepsiCo, urging the company to improve margins and consider divesting low-margin brands [7][8] Group 4: Dividend and Valuation Insights - PepsiCo's dividend yield is currently at 3.99%, with an annual dividend of $5.69 and a payout ratio of 103.64% [9] - The stock appears reasonably valued at around 17.2x forward earnings, trading at a discount to its historical average and the consumer staples sector average [11]