网络“维权”变“侵权”？互联网法庭判了！

Core Viewpoint - The rise of short video platforms has led to an increase in individuals using these platforms for rights protection, but there is a fine line between legitimate claims and defamation, as illustrated by a recent court case involving a defamation dispute stemming from a short video posted on Douyin [1][2]. Case Summary - In May 2024, an individual named Zhang was entrusted by Li to handle certain matters for a fee of 30,000 yuan, but after Li terminated the contract, Zhang only refunded 20,000 yuan. Li then posted a video on Douyin accusing Zhang of being a fraud, which garnered significant attention with nearly 400 shares, over 700 comments, and more than 2,000 likes [2]. - Zhang claimed that Li's video severely damaged his reputation and filed a lawsuit for defamation, seeking compensation for the harm caused [2]. Court Ruling - The court determined that Li's video constituted a negative evaluation of Zhang, and Li failed to provide evidence to support the truthfulness of his claims. The court found that Li's actions resulted in a significant reduction in Zhang's social standing, establishing a clear causal link between Li's defamatory statements and the damage to Zhang's reputation [3]. - Although Li deleted the video before the court hearing, the court ruled that he must publicly apologize to Zhang on Douyin, aligning the scope of the apology with the extent of the infringement [3]. Legal Implications - The case highlights the legal boundaries of free speech in the context of online platforms, emphasizing that while individuals have the right to express their opinions, they must not infringe upon the legitimate rights of others, particularly regarding defamation [4]. - The court's decision reinforces the notion that online statements must be truthful and lawful, as failure to adhere to these standards can lead to legal repercussions, including the obligation to cease infringement and restore the injured party's reputation [4][5]. Recommendations for Individuals - Individuals facing online defamation should preserve evidence such as screenshots, links, and comments to support their claims [7]. - They should utilize reporting mechanisms on social media platforms to request the removal of infringing content and seek assistance in identifying the infringer [7]. - In cases of serious defamation, individuals are advised to report to law enforcement and consider filing civil lawsuits to seek damages and public apologies [8][9].