Some PepsiCo investors are still cautious about Elliott's plan to spin out bottling

Core Viewpoint - Some investors in PepsiCo support Elliott Investment Management's suggestions to cut costs and eliminate underperforming brands, but are cautious about the proposal to separate the bottling network [1][5]. Group 1: Elliott's Proposal - Elliott Investment Management has proposed that PepsiCo should consider spinning off its bottling business to increase margins and simplify operations, similar to a move made by Coca-Cola nearly a decade ago [2][4]. - Elliott has taken a $4 billion stake in PepsiCo and released a report outlining strategies to boost profits, as the company's share price has fallen nearly 20% over the past year, underperforming the S&P consumer staples index [3]. Group 2: Financial Performance - PepsiCo's operating margins were reported at 14% last year, an increase from 13.1% in 2023, while Coca-Cola's margins were significantly higher at 21.2% and 24.7% for the same periods [6][7]. - The North American beverage business of PepsiCo has operating margins trailing Coca-Cola's by as much as 10 percentage points, which could potentially be recovered through refranchising [6]. Group 3: Investor Sentiment - Some long-term investors express concerns that separating the bottling business could be costly and time-consuming, potentially impacting PepsiCo's margins and earnings negatively during the transition [5]. - Ongoing discussions between Elliott and PepsiCo indicate that the company is reviewing the proposals while maintaining an active dialogue with shareholders [6].