Chewy Stock: Why Analysts Say Boring May Be the Best Buy

Core Viewpoint - The current market environment, characterized by high S&P 500 levels and Federal Reserve rate cuts, suggests that stable, cash-generating businesses like Chewy may be more attractive to investors seeking safety amid volatility [1][4]. Company Overview - Chewy operates a subscription-based model that provides revenue predictability and has a loyal customer base, making it resilient in uncertain economic conditions [4][5]. - The stock is currently priced at $40.19, with a 52-week range between $26.28 and $48.62, and a P/E ratio of 114.69 [4]. Analyst Sentiment - Analysts have raised their price targets for Chewy, with a consensus target of $45.84, indicating a potential upside of approximately 16% from current levels [6][7]. - Some analysts, like Michael Morton from Moffett Nathanson, have issued a Buy rating with a target of $48, suggesting a 21% upside [7]. Financial Metrics - Chewy has a gross profit margin of 29.5% and a return on invested capital (ROIC) of 15.7%, which are strong indicators of the company's efficiency and long-term performance potential [8]. - Despite a high P/E ratio of 113.3x, which is significantly above the retail sector average of 20.2x, investors are still showing interest, reflecting expectations of future growth [9]. Institutional Activity - In August 2025, Invesco Ltd. increased its stake in Chewy by 34.7%, indicating institutional confidence in the company [10]. - Chewy's management repurchased a $500 million stake from BC Partners, signaling strong insider confidence in the company's long-term value [11].