Is ESG Investing Losing Its Shine? ESG Stocks Continue To Underperform The S&P 500

Core Insights - ESG stocks have significantly underperformed compared to the S&P 500, with the Kiplinger ESG 20 returning an average of 4.3% over the past year, which is less than one-third of the S&P 500's 15.9% return [1] - Only six out of the 15 stocks in the Kiplinger ESG 20 outperformed the S&P 500, and only one of the favored ESG funds did so [1] Group 1: ESG Performance Challenges - ESG investing faced hurdles last year due to social media pressure, leading companies to retreat from their ESG objectives [2] - Morningstar reported that 2023 was the worst calendar year for ESG stocks, with lagging performance cited as the primary reason for this underperformance [3][4] - High interest rates and supply chain disruptions were noted as contributing factors to the underperformance of ESG stocks, although these challenges affected all sectors [4] Group 2: AI Stocks and ESG - Despite the energy-intensive nature of AI, several AI stocks, including Microsoft and Nvidia, were included in the Kiplinger ESG 20 list, raising questions about the criteria for ESG classification [6][7] - Microsoft's commitment to being carbon negative and water positive by 2030 justified its inclusion, while Nvidia's board and compensation practices were highlighted as reasons for its selection [8]