Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the repeated incidents of plagiarism in submissions to the journal "Tsinghua Journal of Western Philosophy," emphasizing the need for stricter measures against academic misconduct and the importance of maintaining academic integrity in research environments [1][2][3]. Group 1: Journal's Response to Plagiarism - The journal has issued a statement regarding a recent plagiarism incident, indicating that this is the third occurrence, and warns that future serious academic misconduct will lead to severe consequences, including public criticism [1]. - The journal, founded in 2015, aims to promote the professionalization and internationalization of Western philosophy research in China and has been recognized as a high-impact academic journal [1]. Group 2: Concerns Over Inconsistent Treatment - There are concerns about the journal's inconsistent handling of plagiarism cases, particularly if the same author repeatedly submits plagiarized work while receiving leniency, which raises questions about fairness and the integrity of the academic process [2]. - The article argues that all authors should be treated equally in cases of academic misconduct, and that leniency towards early offenders undermines the principles of academic integrity [2]. Group 3: Need for Collaborative Action - The investigation and handling of academic misconduct should involve collaboration among various academic institutions and timely information sharing, rather than secrecy or selective disclosure [2][3]. - The article highlights the responsibility of academic journals to disclose misconduct involving affiliated individuals and the potential consequences of failing to do so, which can damage the academic environment [3].
再三宽纵投稿抄袭,学术公信还请三思
Nan Fang Du Shi Bao·2025-10-28 04:49