P&G(US:PG) The Motley Fool·2025-11-01 12:53Core Insights - The Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF (VDC) and the iShares US Consumer Staples ETF (IYK) are both focused on leading U.S. consumer staples companies, but they differ in cost, diversification, and portfolio tilt [1] Cost & Size Comparison - IYK has an expense ratio of 0.38%, while VDC is more affordable at 0.09%, making it cheaper by 0.29 percentage points [2][3] - As of October 27, 2025, IYK has an AUM of $1.3 billion, whereas VDC has a significantly larger AUM of $8.5 billion [2] Performance & Risk Metrics - Over the past five years, IYK has a max drawdown of -15.05%, compared to VDC's -16.54% [4] - A $1,000 investment in IYK would have grown to $1,417 over five years, while the same investment in VDC would have grown to $1,344 [4] Holdings Overview - VDC consists of 103 holdings, primarily in the consumer defensive sector (98%), with major positions in Walmart, Costco, and Procter & Gamble [5] - IYK is more concentrated with 55 holdings and includes a 10% allocation to healthcare stocks, featuring top holdings like Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, and Philip Morris International [6] Total Return Analysis - Over the past five years, IYK delivered a total return of 57%, while VDC provided a total return of 51% [8] - In a 10-year timeframe, IYK's total return was 132%, outperforming VDC's 110% [9] Dividend Performance - The latest quarterly dividend payment for VDC was 28.1% lower than five years ago, indicating disappointing cash flow growth for investors [10] - Conversely, IYK's latest dividend payment was 108% higher than the payout from a year earlier, showing positive growth in dividends [10]