Papa Johns’ North America same-store sales drop 2.7% as consumers pull back on spending

Core Insights - Papa Johns is experiencing a cautious consumer environment, leading to mixed performance in the third quarter, with flat same-store sales overall [1][2] - International sales grew by 7.1%, which helped offset a 2.7% decline in North American sales [1] Sales Performance - The company reported flat revenue of $508 million for the third quarter, with net income dropping to $4 million, or 13 cents per share, compared to $42 million, or $1.27 per share, in the same quarter last year [6] - The adjusted financial outlook for 2025 now projects a decline of 2% to 2.5% in same-store sales for North America, down from a previous estimate of flat to up 2% [6] Consumer Behavior - Weaker consumer sentiment and a more promotional quick-service restaurant (QSR) marketplace are impacting sales, particularly in North America [2] - Customers are focusing on "center of plate" items, such as large pizzas, and are opting to remove extras from their orders to save money [2] Promotions and Strategies - To attract lower-income customers, the company introduced a 50% off carryout promotion, which has shown to improve order trends [3][4] - The promotion is seen as a way to encourage customers to build a more comprehensive order once they engage with the offer [4] - The company is balancing promotional value with store-level profitability while investing in operational efficiencies and expanding in international markets like India [5]