Dividends Up To 20% Wall Street Says You Should Sell

Core Viewpoint - The article discusses a selection of stocks with high dividend yields that are currently viewed unfavorably by Wall Street analysts, suggesting potential investment opportunities in these "hated" stocks. Group 1: Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) - National Storage Affiliates Trust (NSA) has a yield of 7.9% and operates 1,069 properties across 37 states and Puerto Rico, benefiting from a recession-resistant business model, although it is currently facing a 20% pullback in performance [3][4] - NSA's recent quarter showed declines in earnings, core FFO, same store net operating income, and occupancy, reflecting broader challenges in the self-storage sector rather than unique issues for NSA [3][4] - Alexander's (ALX) has an 8.5% yield and is highly concentrated, with 60% of its revenues coming from tenant Bloomberg. The company is in discussions for loan restructuring after failing to repay a $300 million loan [5][6] - Despite challenges, ALX has shown double-digit total returns in 2025, outperforming the broader real estate sector, but Wall Street remains skeptical due to dividend concerns [7] Group 2: Talent Solutions and Consulting - Robert Half (RHI) has a yield of 9.0% and operates in contract talent solutions, permanent placement, and consulting services. The company has seen its stock price drop 80% since its peak in 2022, leading to more Sell and Hold ratings than Buys [10][11] - The decline in RHI's stock is attributed to a post-COVID hiring moderation, with significant job losses reported, although the company believes the impact of AI on its business is overstated [12][13] - RHI's earnings are expected to drop by 45% this year, raising concerns about dividend coverage as the payout is projected to exceed earnings through at least the end of 2026 [14] Group 3: Crafting and Creativity Platform - Cricut (CRCT) boasts a high yield of 20.6% and operates as a creativity platform, offering machines and software for crafting. The company initiated a new semiannual dividend program despite declining profits [16][17] - The stock has seen a significant decline, leading to a yield increase above 20%, with analysts recommending selling the stock [19] - Despite a loyal user base and expected profit growth of over 20% in 2025, Cricut faces challenges with flat or declining revenues projected in the coming years, particularly if economic conditions affect holiday shopping [20][21]