Carnival vs. Royal Caribbean: Which Cruise Stock Is the Better Buy Now?

Core Insights - Carnival Corporation & plc (CCL) and Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. (RCL) are leading the recovery of the global cruise industry, benefiting from strong travel demand and record onboard spending trends [1] - Investors are evaluating which company presents a more attractive investment opportunity as the sector shifts from post-pandemic recovery to sustained profitability [2] Carnival Corporation (CCL) - CCL's third-quarter fiscal 2025 results indicate strong performance with record revenues, net income, and yields, alongside impressive onboard spending [3] - Customer deposits reached a new high in Q3 fiscal 2025, indicating strong booking momentum and pricing power for 2026 [4] - The company is improving its financial position, reducing leverage to 3.6x and approaching investment-grade metrics, which may lead to dividends and buybacks [4] - CCL's commercial initiatives, including exclusive destinations and a multi-brand strategy, are enhancing ticket prices and guest experiences [5] - Despite progress, CCL faces challenges such as high net interest expenses and ongoing leverage reduction efforts, with potential margin pressures from a new loyalty program and increased operational costs [6] Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. (RCL) - RCL is capitalizing on a strong global demand for leisure travel, with high guest satisfaction and robust booking trends for 2025 and 2026 [7] - The company is achieving margin growth through cost discipline and technology efficiencies, expecting minimal cost growth while expanding destination offerings [8] - RCL is focusing on its competitive advantages, including innovative ships and exclusive destinations, which are driving onboard revenue [9] - However, RCL anticipates challenges such as increased fuel costs, regulatory expenses, and structural costs from new destination rollouts [12] Financial Performance and Valuation - The Zacks Consensus Estimate for CCL indicates fiscal 2026 sales and EPS growth of 4.3% and 10.8%, respectively, with upward revisions in earnings estimates [13] - RCL's estimates imply year-over-year growth of 9.4% in sales and 14.5% in EPS, but have seen downward revisions recently [14] - RCL's stock has increased by 10% over the past six months, while CCL's shares have risen by 19.4% [15] - CCL's forward P/E ratio is 11.09X, below its median of 12.96X, while RCL's is 14.94X, below its median of 18.13X [20] Conclusion - CCL appears to offer a more compelling investment opportunity due to its operational turnaround, improving financial health, and strong stock momentum [18] - Both companies are positioned well in the market, with CCL focusing on enhancing destinations and yield, while RCL maintains strong demand trends [21]