Has KMX Stock Been Good for Investors?

Company Performance - CarMax has significantly underperformed the S&P 500, with a 56% decline in stock price over the past year compared to a 13% increase in the S&P 500 [3] - Over three years, CarMax's stock has decreased by 43.6%, while the S&P 500 has risen by 68% [3] - In the last five years, CarMax's stock has dropped by 60.5%, against an 86% increase in the S&P 500 [3] Industry Challenges - The used car market has faced numerous challenges since early 2020, including squeezed gross margins and decreased demand due to high vehicle prices [4] - Increased competition from digital-first competitors like Carvana has negatively impacted CarMax's fiscal performance [4] Recent Developments - CarMax's recent stock decline followed worse-than-expected guidance and the unexpected resignation of CEO Bill Nash, effective December 1 [7] - The company has initiated a turnaround plan that includes targeted cost savings of $150 million over the next 18 months [7] Future Outlook - If CarMax's turnaround efforts coincide with improved demand in the coming year, the company could see a return to improved financial results [8] - Currently, CarMax shares trade at a forward P/E ratio of 10, which is below the historical range of 15 to 20 times earnings, suggesting potential for valuation expansion [8] - There is a possibility for CarMax to achieve market-beating returns if profitability improves and valuation expands in the future [9]