FITB vs. MTB: Which Regional Bank Stock Looks More Attractive Now?
ZACKS·2025-12-03 16:56

Core Insights - The article highlights the resilience of regional banks, specifically Fifth Third Bancorp (FITB) and M&T Bank (MTB), in a changing banking environment influenced by interest rate shifts and consumer credit trends [1] Group 1: Fifth Third Bancorp (FITB) - FITB is set to become the ninth-largest U.S. bank following its merger with Comerica, which will create a bank with nearly $288 billion in assets, $224 billion in deposits, and $174 billion in loans [3] - The bank has focused on expanding its commercial payments platform and private credit offerings, with expectations for its commercial payments segment to grow into a $1 billion business within five years [5] - FITB's long-term strategy includes aggressive geographic expansion, particularly in the Southeast, with plans to open 200 retail locations by 2028, anticipating $15-20 billion in deposit growth over the next seven years [6] - Management expects adjusted net interest income (NII) to rise by 5.5-6.5% in 2025 from $5.66 billion reported in 2024, aided by a favorable lending environment and stabilized funding costs [7] Group 2: M&T Bank (MTB) - MTB has demonstrated strong revenue growth, with management projecting 2025 NII to be between $7.05 billion and $7.15 billion, alongside non-interest income expected to be between $2.5 billion and $2.6 billion [8] - The bank's solid balance sheet is supported by the acquisition of People's United in 2022, which increased loans by $36 billion and deposits by $53 billion [9] - MTB anticipates average loan and lease balances between $135 billion and $137 billion in 2025, with total deposit balances expected to be between $162 billion and $164 billion [11] Group 3: Comparative Analysis - Over the past six months, FITB shares have increased by 13.8%, while MTB shares have risen by 6.2%, compared to the industry's growth of 17.7% [12] - FITB is trading at a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 11.07X, while MTB is at 10.29X, both below the industry average of 11.39X [15][17] - FITB has a dividend yield of 3.7% after an 8.1% increase in its dividend, while MTB's yield is 3.1% following an 11.1% increase [18] Group 4: Growth Potential - The Zacks Consensus Estimate indicates FITB's sales will grow by 6.4% in 2025 and 4.8% in 2026, with earnings expected to increase by 4.8% and 12.9% respectively [20] - For MTB, sales are projected to grow by 4.4% in 2025 and 3.6% in 2026, with earnings expected to rise by 12.4% and 11.9% respectively [22] - FITB's clearer multi-year growth narrative, driven by its Southeast expansion and the Comerica merger, positions it favorably compared to MTB, which maintains steady growth but lacks immediate catalysts [25][26]