These Big BDC Yields Look Tempting But Come With Even Bigger Risks
Forbes·2025-12-09 15:10

Core Viewpoint - The bankruptcy of auto-parts supplier First Brands has raised concerns about the business development companies (BDCs) market, which is known for high dividends, prompting investors to question whether these assets are now bargains [2][3]. Group 1: Market Concerns - The bankruptcy of First Brands has led to increased scrutiny of the private-credit market where BDCs operate, with JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon suggesting there may be more issues within this sector [3]. - BDCs are facing challenges as investors are wary of potential risks associated with high yields that may be linked to declining stock prices [2][4]. Group 2: Specific BDC Analysis - Blue Owl Capital (OBDC) is highlighted as a BDC with high fees, including a 1.5% base management fee and a 17.5% cut of net investment income, which raises concerns about its attractiveness despite its 11.9% yield [6][7]. - OBDC has not outperformed the BDC market since its IPO in 2019, indicating that its performance is not compelling enough to justify its fees [8]. - Prospect Capital Corp (PSEC) is noted for being the cheapest BDC on the market, trading at a 60% discount to NAV, but its long-term return of 7% over the last decade and a 20.9% current yield signal potential risks [8][9]. Group 3: Alternative Investment Opportunities - The Liberty All-Star Growth Fund (ASG) is presented as a more favorable investment option, having achieved a 175% total return over the last decade, significantly outperforming BDCs [11]. - ASG offers a predictable dividend tied to its portfolio performance, committing to pay about 8% of NAV annually, and currently trades at an 11.2% discount to NAV, making it an attractive alternative to BDCs [12][13].