CVX vs. SU: Which 2026 Plan Offers Better Upside for Investors
ZACKS·2025-12-12 14:25

Core Insights - 2026 is a pivotal year for Chevron Corporation and Suncor Energy, with both companies outlining operational plans and capital priorities that will shape their financial and strategic paths [1][19] Chevron Corporation - Chevron's 2026 plan includes major upstream catalysts, such as the Tengizchevroil expansion and Gulf of America deepwater projects, with the Permian Basin expected to reach 1 million barrels of oil equivalent per day [3][4] - The company anticipates an additional $12.5 billion in annual free cash flow by 2026, supported by disciplined capital spending and a resilient asset base [4] - Chevron aims for $3 to $4 billion in structural cost reductions, with over 60% expected from efficiency gains, enhancing unit economics across its global portfolio [5][6] - The company maintains a consistent shareholder-return framework, planning to repurchase $10 to $20 billion in shares annually, adjusted for commodity prices [6] - Chevron's diversified asset base reduces exposure to any single market or commodity stream, supported by low-breakeven barrels and a strong balance sheet [6][20] Suncor Energy - Suncor's structural advantage lies in its low corporate decline rate and stability of long-life oil sands assets, with near-zero decline in mining and upgrading operations [7][10] - The company's business model supports predictable free-funds-flow generation, even in mid-$60 WTI environments, through disciplined sustaining capital and targeted economic investments [8][9] - Suncor has executed best-ever turnaround durations at multiple assets, lowering its WTI breakeven by $7 per barrel in 2024, and continues to improve flexibility and durability across its oil sands network [9][11] - The capital-return strategy is assertive, with plans to return nearly 100% of excess funds to shareholders, including buybacks and a dividend targeted to grow 3-5% annually [11][12] - Suncor's integrated network helps cushion price volatility, despite being more concentrated in oil sands [12] Price Performance - Year-to-date, Suncor shares are up 24.2%, significantly outperforming Chevron's 4.1% gain, reflecting improving sentiment around Suncor's operational execution [13] Valuation Comparison - Suncor trades at a lower forward P/E of just above 16X compared to Chevron's roughly 19X, making Suncor more appealing for value-oriented investors [14][20] Earnings Estimates - Suncor's EPS estimates have remained stable, while Chevron's estimates for 2025 and 2026 have moved lower due to near-term uncertainties [16][18] Conclusion - While both companies hold a Zacks Rank 3 (Hold), Suncor's stronger stock performance, attractive valuation, and steadier earnings estimates position it favorably heading into 2026 [19][20]