American Banker·2025-12-15 11:00Core Viewpoint - Activist investor HoldCo Asset Management plans to vote against Comerica's proposed sale to Fifth Third Bancorp, believing that Comerica could secure a better offer elsewhere [1][9]. Group 1: Activist Investor's Position - HoldCo Asset Management has launched activist campaigns against Comerica and other banks, asserting that there is "significant upside and limited downside" in opposing the transaction [2]. - The firm criticizes the negotiation process as "unacceptable" and has initiated a lawsuit against Comerica and Fifth Third in Delaware [3]. - HoldCo holds approximately $200 million in Comerica stock, representing about 1.8% of the outstanding shares [4]. Group 2: Transaction Details - The proposed sale is valued at nearly $11 billion, marking it as the largest bank deal announced in 2025 [5]. - The negotiation timeline of 17 days is noted as the fastest among major acquisitions [5]. - Fifth Third's CEO Tim Spence expressed confidence in the deal's approval and highlighted potential revenue opportunities of $500 million over the next three to five years [7][8]. Group 3: Legal and Regulatory Context - Shareholder votes for both Comerica and Fifth Third are scheduled for January 6, with ongoing legal proceedings that may influence the outcome [12]. - A Delaware judge will hold a hearing on January 2 to address HoldCo's claims regarding inadequate disclosures about the deal [14]. - The deal could close as early as February 2, depending on the outcome of the shareholder votes and legal proceedings [16]. Group 4: Market Reactions and Opinions - Analysts from TD Securities have expressed disagreement with HoldCo's assertion that Comerica could find a better offer, suggesting that the deal is favorable for both banks [16]. - An anonymous group, the Comerica 175 Coalition, has also opposed the deal, raising concerns about the negotiation process and requesting a public hearing [17].