厕所门遇烟变透明?控烟不能只靠“社死威慑”

Core Viewpoint - The installation of "smoking transparent" toilet doors in a Shenzhen shopping mall has sparked widespread debate, highlighting the challenges of smoking control in public restrooms, which are both public spaces and private areas [1] Group 1: Technology and Governance - The "smoking transparent" design represents an attempt to replace administrative enforcement with moral deterrence, creating psychological pressure through potential exposure [2] - This approach risks institutionalizing shame and could lead to online harassment, as the technology may not distinguish between different types of smoke, leading to privacy violations [2] - The reliance on technology for governance may obscure the lack of accountability and responsibility in management, as it substitutes for ongoing human effort and institutional design [2] Group 2: Alternative Solutions - Public space managers should avoid relying on "automatic transparency" as a one-size-fits-all solution for smoking control, advocating for more systematic and humane approaches [3] - Utilizing smoke detection technology to trigger sound alarms or notify cleaning and security personnel could effectively address violations while respecting privacy [3] - A mature society should balance public interest with individual dignity, ensuring that governance methods do not compromise personal respect and privacy [3]