HIMS vs. TDOC: Which Telehealth Stock Looks More Compelling?

Core Insights - Virtual care is becoming a mainstream healthcare channel, with Hims & Hers Health, Inc. (HIMS) and Teladoc Health, Inc. (TDOC) utilizing digital-first models to enhance access [2][3] Company Overview - HIMS operates as a consumer-first, subscription-based telehealth platform, allowing users to discover treatments online, consult licensed providers, and receive recurring prescriptions through its integrated digital pharmacy [2] - TDOC is a global leader in virtual care, providing services through its Integrated Care segment, which includes virtual medical visits and chronic care programs, as well as BetterHelp, its online therapy platform [2] Stock Performance & Valuation - Over the past three months, HIMS has decreased by 37.4%, while TDOC has declined by 9.7%. However, in the past year, HIMS has increased by 22.1%, contrasting with TDOC's loss of 22.5% [4] - HIMS is trading at a forward 12-month price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of 2.9X, above its three-year median of 2.6X, while TDOC's forward sales multiple is at 0.5X, below its median of 0.7X [6] Growth Strategies - HIMS is expanding into low testosterone care, integrating at-home lab testing with personalized treatment plans, and collaborating with Marius Pharmaceuticals to launch an exclusive branded oral testosterone by 2026 [8][10] - The introduction of Hims & Hers Labs aims to enhance customer engagement through diagnostics and biomarker tracking, supporting a more personalized healthcare model [9] - HIMS is also accelerating international expansion, having entered Canada and launched a Weight Loss Programme in the U.K. [10] Teladoc Health's Positioning - TDOC is focusing on building an integrated enterprise-scale virtual care platform, enhancing its offerings in primary care, chronic condition management, and mental health [11] - The company is expanding its hospital capabilities, introducing new tools for operational support and care-team workflows, with a new workplace safety capability expected to launch in early 2026 [12] - TDOC is working on stabilizing performance and improving execution across its segments, with recent results reflecting steady progress [13] Earnings Projections - The Zacks Consensus Estimate for HIMS' 2025 earnings per share (EPS) suggests a 77.8% improvement from 2024 [15] - For TDOC, the 2025 loss per share is expected to improve by 79.7% from 2024 [17] Price Targets - Analysts project an average price target of $45.92 for HIMS, indicating a potential increase of 31.9% from the last close [19] - For TDOC, the average price target is $9.18, suggesting a 27.3% increase from the last close [20] Investment Recommendation - HIMS is viewed as a more stable and financially sound investment opportunity due to its expanding specialty offerings and international growth strategy [22] - TDOC remains a leading enterprise-focused provider but is more exposed to demand cycles and segment-level volatility [23]