Don't Call It a Comeback

Chipotle - Chipotle's stock has fallen 51% from its high in 2024, with negative same-store sales reported [1] - The company opened about 200 new locations, but average unit volumes have dropped by approximately 3%, which is unusual for Chipotle [2] - Chipotle has a strong financial position, earning $1.5 billion in net income over the past year and holding $1.8 billion in cash with no debt other than lease liabilities [3] - The company is investing in menu innovation and has seen success with limited-time offerings, which encourage repeat visits [5] - Approximately 40% of Chipotle's sales come from households earning under $100,000, a demographic currently facing inflationary pressures [5] - Chipotle plans to open 350-370 new restaurants in 2026 and is focusing on international expansion [5] - The stock trades at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 30, down from 70 in mid-2024, indicating a significant valuation adjustment [6][7] Target - Target's stock is down 46% over the past five years, with inconsistent same-store sales performance [10] - The stock trades at a low forward P/E ratio of around 11, but the company maintains strong fundamentals, including an A credit rating and nearly $5 billion in cash [10] - Target is facing challenges related to consumer backlash and competition from rivals like Walmart, impacting its market share [10] - A new CEO, Michael Fidelki, is set to implement a multi-year plan to reinvigorate private label brands and key discretionary categories [11] - Target aims to drive over $15 billion in revenue growth over the next five years, but significant changes are needed for this to materialize [11] - The market is skeptical about Target's growth potential, reflected in its high dividend yield of about 5% [14] Crocs - Crocs' stock is down 23% over the past year, trading at just seven times forward earnings estimates [19] - The company faced challenges after acquiring Hey Dude, leading to bloated inventory and a goodwill impairment charge [19][21] - Despite domestic sales softness, Crocs is experiencing strong double-digit growth in international markets [25] - The brand maintains strong margins and is actively managing its capital structure, including share repurchases [21] - Crocs has successfully engaged in high-profile collaborations, which have helped revitalize its brand image [23]