法治在线丨遗嘱、遗赠扶养协议怎样订立才有效？一文了解

Group 1 - The core issue revolves around the validity of two wills and whether a non-legal heir can be designated as a beneficiary [1][4][20] - The first will was established in 1998 and was notarized, indicating that the property should be inherited by the daughter and her husband [4][20] - The second will was discovered later, leading to a dispute among the siblings regarding the inheritance rights [7][11] Group 2 - The court ruled that the notarized will was legally valid, and the husband of the daughter was entitled to inherit the property as a beneficiary [20][24] - The key legal point was when the husband became aware of the will, which determined his right to accept the inheritance [16][18] - The court emphasized that the relationship between the husband and the daughter did not automatically imply prior knowledge of the will [20][22] Group 3 - In a separate case, the validity of two different caregiving agreements signed by an elderly man was questioned, focusing on which agreement would be honored [25][27] - The first agreement was signed in 2008 with a niece, while a second agreement was signed in 2014 with other relatives, leading to disputes over inheritance rights [33][43] - The court found that the first agreement remained valid as there was no evidence of its revocation, and the niece had fulfilled her caregiving obligations [45][47]