3 Insurers to Buy Heading Into 2026 as High Rates Boost Yields
ZACKS·2025-12-29 17:50

Core Insights - Insurance stocks are seen as a strong investment opportunity leading into 2026, driven by disciplined underwriting, steady premium growth, and a favorable interest-rate environment [1] - The Federal Reserve's rate cuts have not brought rates down to the near-zero levels of the past decade, creating a supportive landscape for insurers with long-duration investment portfolios [1] Group 1: Investment Environment - Insurers are benefiting from higher bond yields, which enhance investment income without increasing underwriting risk [2][3] - The gradual turnover of investment portfolios allows insurers to replace lower-yielding bonds with higher-yielding ones, positively impacting earnings over time [3] - Improved investment income strengthens capital positions, enabling dividends, share repurchases, and greater balance-sheet flexibility [3] Group 2: Premium Growth and Underwriting - Insurers are experiencing premium growth due to pricing increases that address inflation, higher claims severity, and catastrophe risks, leading to improved underwriting margins [4] - Strong underwriting discipline and attractive product offerings are driving higher premiums, reinforcing earnings momentum [4] - The combination of prudent underwriting and a healthier rate environment is expected to create a foundation for predictable earnings growth through 2026 [4] Group 3: Company-Specific Insights - Mercury General Corporation (MCY) is positioned for top-line growth, benefiting from sustained premium increases and a high percentage of investments in fixed maturity securities [6][7] - Heritage Insurance Holdings (HRTG) is focusing on rate adequacy and disciplined market re-entry, with a significant portion of its investments in fixed maturity securities [8][11] - RenaissanceRe Holdings (RNR) is experiencing strong premium growth driven by demand for reinsurance and favorable market conditions, with a solid investment portfolio [12][13]