Xin Lang Ke Ji·2026-01-14 15:31Group 1 - Ningxia Unicom has implemented a policy requiring users under 24 years old to present a stamped application form to obtain a mobile plan, citing concerns over potential fraud involving young users [1][2][3] - The initial definition of "under 24 years old" as "low-age users" has been updated to "ages 16-23," and the requirement for a stamped application form now only applies to users applying for a second phone number [2][3] - The customer service representative indicated that the majority of users in this age group are students who may lack social experience and legal awareness, making them vulnerable to scams [3] Group 2 - Experts have criticized the policy, arguing that labeling users under 24 as "low-age users" and imposing additional requirements constitutes age discrimination and lacks sufficient justification [4] - The expert noted that international practices typically only classify minors (under 18) as needing special protection, suggesting that the current approach is inconsistent with industry norms [4] - While the intention to prevent fraud is acknowledged, the expert argues that the measures taken may not be proportionate or necessary, as existing regulations already address most risk scenarios [4]