Core Viewpoint - The decision by Panama's top court to void CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd.'s contract to operate two ports has been criticized by a pro-Beijing newspaper, which claims the ruling is influenced by US pressure and urges Hong Kong businesses to reconsider investments in Panama [1][2][3]. Group 1: Judicial Independence and Economic Implications - The ruling reflects Panama's lack of judicial independence and its readiness to accommodate US demands, as stated in a commentary from Ta Kung Pao [2]. - The two ports are part of CK Hutchison's proposed sale of 43 global facilities to a consortium that includes China Cosco Shipping Corp., Terminal Investment Ltd., and BlackRock Inc. [2]. - The newspaper calls for Panama to correct the ruling and compensate affected companies, warning that failure to do so could harm economic ties with China and diminish confidence among Chinese enterprises [3]. Group 2: Geopolitical Context and Investment Risks - The article indicates rising tensions between the US and China over the strategic Panama Canal, complicating the ports sale by CK Hutchison, which could generate over $19 billion in cash if completed [4]. - CK Hutchison's decision to invite state-owned Cosco into the buying consortium was seen as a response to US pressure, with the US Secretary of State praising the ruling as a positive development [5][4]. - The commentary suggests that the ruling poses significant risks to global business operations and serves as a warning to investors [9]. Group 3: Strategic Moves and Future Considerations - To mitigate regulatory risks, the involved parties are considering splitting the assets into separate parcels with different ownership structures, allowing Cosco to take larger stakes in ports located in more China-friendly regions [6]. - The commentary criticizes Panama for its military cooperation with the US and for withdrawing from China's Belt and Road Initiative, indicating a shift in diplomatic relations [8]. - Prior to Cosco's involvement, China had threatened investigations into the deal and instructed state-owned enterprises to cease collaboration with the Li family, highlighting the political tensions affecting business operations [10].
Pro-Beijing Paper Blasts Panama’s Ruling Against CK Hutchison