XLP Delivers Pure-Play Staples While IYK Adds Healthcare. Which Strategy Wins?

Core Insights - The State Street Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLP) and the iShares US Consumer Staples ETF (IYK) provide exposure to the U.S. consumer staples sector, with XLP being more cost-effective and focused on consumer defensive stocks, while IYK includes healthcare stocks and has a broader portfolio [1][2][9] Cost Comparison - XLP has an expense ratio of 0.08%, significantly lower than IYK's 0.38%, making it more appealing for long-term cost-conscious investors [3][4] - Both ETFs offer a dividend yield of 2.75% [3] Performance Metrics - The 1-year return for XLP is 9.9%, while IYK has a higher return of 11.3% [3] - Over five years, XLP experienced a maximum drawdown of 16.31%, compared to IYK's 15.04% [5] - A $1,000 investment in XLP would have grown to $1,302 over five years, while IYK would have grown to $1,222 [5] Portfolio Composition - IYK holds 54 positions, with 85% in consumer defensive stocks, 11% in healthcare, and 2% in basic materials, featuring top holdings like Procter & Gamble (14.25%), Coca-Cola (11.70%), and Philip Morris International (11.31%) [5][6] - XLP maintains a concentrated portfolio of 36 stocks, exclusively in the consumer defensive sector, with major holdings in Walmart, Costco, and Procter & Gamble [6][8] Investment Strategy - XLP is suitable for investors seeking pure, low-cost exposure to consumer staples, particularly those who believe in the long-term potential of retail giants like Walmart and Costco [9] - IYK may appeal to those looking for diversification beyond consumer staples, including healthcare exposure, albeit at a significantly higher fee [9]