Core Viewpoint - The discussion highlights the ongoing debate in the AI medical field, emphasizing that while AI has potential, it is not yet fully reliable, and the importance of continuing to train and value human doctors remains critical [1][2]. Group 1: Perspectives on AI in Healthcare - Huang Wei acknowledges that both Zhang Wenhong and Wang Xiaochuan present valid points regarding the role of AI in medicine, with Zhang focusing on the current limitations of AI and the need for ongoing doctor training [2]. - The core argument from Zhang Wenhong is that AI should not be fully relied upon at this stage, and there should be a pathway for doctors to grow and evolve in their roles [2]. - Wang Xiaochuan's perspective emphasizes patient autonomy and the ideal scenario where AI can assist without compromising the growth of medical professionals [2]. Group 2: AI Reliability and Patient Interaction - Huang Wei points out that many patients may use AI tools like DeepSeek to self-diagnose, but they often overlook the high error rates associated with such AI models, which do not take responsibility for their conclusions [2]. - The discussion illustrates the tension between the ideal use of AI in healthcare and the current reality where AI cannot replace the need for human doctors [2].
张文宏反对电子病历引热议，云知声黄伟：AI不能替代医生成长