XRT Is Up 11% But the Real Story Is Which Retailers Are Winning
247Wallst·2026-02-18 18:03

Core Insights - The SPDR S&P Retail ETF (XRT) has shown an 11.05% return over the past year, but its performance has slowed with only a 2.47% increase year-to-date and a 3.34% decline in the past month, indicating uncertainty in consumer spending [1] Retail Performance - Walmart (WMT) exceeded revenue estimates by $4.33 billion, driven by a 27% surge in eCommerce sales, resulting in a 15.65% stock increase year-to-date [1] - TJX Companies reported a 5% rise in comparable sales and a 7.49% increase in total revenue, benefiting from consumers shifting towards value retailers [1] - Dollar General (DG) achieved a 37.6% EPS beat and 2.5% same-store sales growth, reflecting the trend of value-seeking consumer behavior [1] - Target (TGT) experienced an 18.91% decline in operating income, struggling to maintain competitiveness without a clear value proposition [1] Consumer Spending Trends - The performance of XRT is closely tied to U.S. consumer spending, with December 2025 retail sales reported at $735 billion, flat month-over-month but up 3.3% year-over-year [1] - A decline in monthly growth below 2% or consecutive negative months could exert downward pressure on XRT, compressing margins across its holdings [1] - The University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index is at 52.9, indicating recessionary territory, with sustained readings below 50 signaling potential spending declines [1] Equal-Weight Methodology - XRT's equal-weight structure allows smaller retailers to have the same influence as larger ones, which can lead to significant performance shifts during quarterly rebalancing events [1] - Monitoring State Street's monthly holdings files and quarterly rebalance announcements is crucial for understanding potential changes in exposure to discount versus full-price retail [1]