中金:美股“泡沫”破裂了吗?——与互联网泡沫的对比
中金点睛·2025-03-19 00:15

Core Viewpoint - Since 2025, US stocks, particularly tech giants, have underperformed globally, with recent significant declines contrasting sharply with the strong performance of Hong Kong tech stocks, raising investor concerns about the potential bubble risk in US tech stocks [1] Group 1: Current Market Status - The S&P 500 and Nasdaq indices have dropped 10% and 14% from their historical highs, respectively, reaching support levels around 5600 and 17700 [3][23] - The S&P 500's dynamic P/E has decreased to 20 times, down 11% from 22.6 times at the end of 2024, while the Nasdaq's dynamic P/E has fallen to 24.6 times, a 19% drop from 30.2 times [3][23] - The average decline for tech giants exceeds 20%, with Tesla's valuation dropping nearly 50% from its peak [3][23] - The market capitalization of the top seven US tech companies has decreased to 26%, still above the 22% before the internet bubble burst, but their profit share of 21% is significantly higher than the 9% at that time [3][23] Group 2: Historical Context and Comparisons - The current market situation is compared to the internet bubble, indicating that the current bubble level is not extreme and resembles the pre-bubble period of 1997-1998 [4] - Since the launch of ChatGPT at the end of 2022, the AI market has seen a 93% increase in the Nasdaq, with profit contributions at 46% and valuation contributions at 32% [5][25] - The previous internet boom lasted nearly nine years, characterized by distinct phases of growth, with the most significant price increases occurring in the final years driven primarily by valuation rather than earnings [5][25] Group 3: Factors Contributing to Bubble Formation - Macro factors include loose monetary policy and inflows of foreign capital into the US, with the Fed's rate cuts in the mid-1990s and the subsequent financial crisis leading to increased liquidity [6][27] - Current monetary conditions are relatively loose, with expectations of rate cuts emerging since early 2023, despite the Fed's actions to stabilize the banking sector [7][28] - Industry policies have supported investment growth, with significant investments in AI technology driven by government initiatives like the CHIPS Act [9][30] Group 4: Market Behavior and Investor Sentiment - The current investment environment is more rational compared to the late 1990s, with a slowdown in venture capital investments and a lower proportion of tech IPOs [11][36] - The proportion of profitable tech companies at IPO has increased to 23%, compared to 14% during the internet bubble, indicating a more cautious investment approach [11][36] - The proportion of stocks and mutual funds in household assets has risen to 26.3%, nearing historical highs, which may amplify market volatility [37] Group 5: Potential Risks and Future Outlook - The potential for a repeat of the significant market rally seen since 2023 hinges on whether the factors contributing to bubble formation can re-emerge, including breakthroughs in AI trends and renewed monetary easing [19][20] - Current market uncertainties, particularly related to policy changes under the Trump administration, could impact investor confidence and market stability [20][21]