‘The Trump administration wants this fight’: Experts weigh in on National Guard troops in Chicago
MSNBC·2025-10-05 13:50

Government Actions & Legal Challenges - The Trump administration authorized deploying 300 National Guard members to Chicago, despite the Illinois Governor's opposition [1][3] - A federal judge in Oregon temporarily blocked the deployment of 200 National Guard troops to Portland, a decision the Trump administration is appealing [1] - The judge in Oregon cited a "long-standing and foundational tradition of resistance to government overreach" in her ruling [4] - The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, known for being liberal, may rule against the administration, though a prior ruling suggests deference to the president on military matters is possible [9][10][12] Political Implications of Government Shutdown - A Washington Post poll indicated 47% of respondents believe Trump and Republicans in Congress are responsible for the government shutdown, while 30% blame Democrats [1] - The shutdown is entering its fifth day with no clear resolution, raising concerns within the Republican party about potential political vulnerabilities related to healthcare subsidies expiring [1] - Democrats believe they have framed the argument effectively around healthcare subsidies, potentially blaming Republicans when premiums increase [30] Messaging & Rhetoric - The administration's rhetoric, including terms like "a war within" and "terrorist organizations within the country," is viewed as divisive and akin to treating the country as if it's in a civil war [22] - Steven Miller's use of hyperbolic language, such as calling the Oregon judge's ruling a "legal insurrection," is seen as potentially problematic for the administration in court [23][24] - The administration's actions, such as deploying federal law enforcement in Blackhawk helicopters, are interpreted by some as sending an intimidating message rather than addressing crime [20]