通往 AGI 之路的苦涩教训

Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the rapid advancement of AI and the potential for achieving Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) within the next 5 to 10 years, as predicted by Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis, who estimates a 50% probability of this achievement [1] Group 1: AI Development and Challenges - The AI wave is accelerating at an unprecedented pace, but there have been numerous missteps along the way, as highlighted by Richard Sutton's 2019 article "The Bitter Lesson," which emphasizes the pitfalls of relying too heavily on human knowledge and intuition [2][4] - Sutton argues that computational power and data are the fundamental engines driving AI forward, rather than human intelligence [3] - The article suggests that many previously held beliefs about the paths to intelligence are becoming obstacles in this new era [4] Group 2: Paths to AGI - The article introduces a discussion on the "bitter lessons" learned on the road to AGI, featuring a dialogue with Liu Jia, a professor at Tsinghua University, who has explored the intersection of AI, brain science, and cognitive science [5][11] - Liu Jia identifies three paths to AGI: reinforcement learning, brain simulation, and natural language processing (NLP), but warns that each path has its own hidden risks [9] - The article emphasizes that language does not equate to cognition, and models do not represent true thought, indicating that while NLP is progressing rapidly, it is not the ultimate destination [9][14] Group 3: Technical Insights - The article discusses the Scaling Law and the illusion of intelligence associated with large models, questioning whether the success of these models is genuine evolution or merely an illusion [15] - It raises concerns about the limitations of brain simulation due to computational bottlenecks and theoretical blind spots, as well as the boundaries of language in relation to understanding the world [14]