拆解“提高财政收入占比”的三个关键问题

Core Viewpoint - The current fiscal pressure in China is closely related to previous constructive debt rather than an increase in "welfare" from enterprises and households. Improving expenditure efficiency and optimizing expenditure structure are crucial for sustainable fiscal health, followed by revenue enhancement [1][5]. Summary by Sections Fiscal Revenue and GDP Ratio - Experts have suggested increasing the fiscal revenue-to-GDP ratio, with former Finance Minister Lou Jiwei advocating for this in his 2025 paper on fiscal policy reform [2]. - The fiscal revenue ratio reflects the government's ability to concentrate financial resources from the economy and its macro-control capacity. China's fiscal revenue includes four main accounts: general public budget, government fund budget, state-owned capital operating budget, and social insurance fund budget [3]. Current Fiscal Situation - The macro tax burden in China is currently at 28.2%, with a reasonable target considered to be around 30%. This indicates room for increasing the fiscal revenue ratio [4]. - The decline in fiscal revenue ratio in recent years is attributed to large-scale tax cuts and fee reductions initiated since 2019, with the ratio dropping from 28-29% in 2018 to 26% in 2023 [9]. Historical Context - Since the tax-sharing system reform in 1994, the fiscal revenue ratio has seen fluctuations, peaking during the "Twelfth Five-Year Plan" at 21.4% and declining to an average of 16.7% during the "Fourteenth Five-Year Plan" [7]. - The fiscal revenue ratio has decreased from 35.7% in 2013 to 30.4% in 2022, a decline of 5.3 percentage points, while the average for 11 middle-income countries increased slightly during the same period [10]. Taxation and Revenue Enhancement - Lou Jiwei has indicated that there is potential to raise the value-added tax (VAT) rate, which currently stands at a low 13%, compared to an average of 20% in other countries [14]. - Other revenue sources, such as social security fund income and land transfer income, have limited growth potential, while the personal income tax has structural weaknesses that make reform challenging [14]. Alternative Revenue Strategies - Experts suggest enhancing the state-owned capital operating budget and reducing unfair tax incentives as alternative methods to increase fiscal revenue without raising tax rates [20][21]. - The state-owned capital operating budget, which is currently underutilized, could significantly contribute to fiscal revenue, especially as land finance declines [21]. Efficiency in Fiscal Spending - Improving the efficiency of government spending and investment is essential for maintaining economic vitality and ensuring public service provision [12][23]. - The focus should be on balancing revenue enhancement with expenditure efficiency, rather than solely increasing the fiscal revenue ratio [18].