Core Viewpoint - The ICLR (International Conference on Learning Representations) has implemented a significant reset of its review process, causing widespread disruption and frustration within the AI research community [2][11]. Group 1: ICLR Review Process Changes - ICLR announced that all Area Chairs (AC) will be reassigned, and all review comments and scores will revert to their initial state prior to discussions [2][11]. - The reset affects nearly 20,000 submissions and over 70,000 reviews, leading to a massive workload increase for the new ACs who must now reassess papers [11]. - The decision has been met with criticism, as many authors feel they are being unfairly punished for the actions of a few, leading to a sense of collective frustration and helplessness [6][11]. Group 2: Community Reactions - The AI community has reacted strongly, with discussions on platforms like Reddit highlighting the challenges faced by authors whose hard work has been undone [10]. - Some authors express that the reset may inadvertently benefit those who previously faced unresponsive reviewers, as it resets the playing field [11]. - There is a growing sentiment that the publication mechanism in machine learning conferences is flawed, with the recent events exposing existing issues in the review process [11].
炸了!ICLR 一键清零 rebuttal,全网研究者怒了
机器之心·2025-11-29 09:33