Core Insights - Costco Wholesale has delivered exceptional returns, with an investment of $10,000 in 1990 growing to over $400,000 today, highlighting its consistent performance [1] - Despite strong historical returns, Costco's current price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of nearly 60 is the highest in over 30 years, raising concerns among investors about its valuation [2] - The article suggests three alternative companies—Floor & Decor, Academy Sports, and BJ's Wholesale Club—that share Costco's business model but are currently valued more attractively [4] Company Summaries Floor & Decor - Floor & Decor operates a high-volume business model similar to Costco, focusing on fewer, larger locations to enhance profitability [5] - The company experienced a 1.8% decline in same-store sales in Q1 2025, reflecting broader trends in the home improvement sector [6] - Despite the slowdown, Floor & Decor maintained a profit margin of 4% in Q1, indicating consistent profitability [7] - The company has plans to double its locations to 500, which could significantly enhance shareholder returns if executed well [8] Academy Sports - Academy Sports also follows a high-volume store model, with 303 locations and aims for first-year sales of $12 million to $16 million per new store, providing operational leverage [9] - The company plans to open 15 to 20 new locations in 2025, contributing to overall sales growth [10] - Academy Sports is currently trading at a P/E ratio of just 8, significantly lower than Costco's, making it an attractive investment option [11] - The company is rewarding shareholders through a growing dividend and stock buybacks, reducing its share count by 20% over the past three years [12] BJ's Wholesale - BJ's Wholesale is the most similar to Costco among the three companies, but it is trading at a valuation more than 50% cheaper than Costco [14] - The company has a strong membership model, with membership fee income increasing annually for 25 years and a renewal rate of 90% [17] - BJ's plans to open 25 to 30 new locations over the next two years, indicating potential for meaningful growth [18] - Overall, Floor & Decor, Academy Sports, and BJ's are positioned to potentially outperform Costco stock over the next five years due to better valuations and growth rates [19]