Political stunt
Search documents
'Political stunt': Retired general slams Trump moving National Guard into U.S. cities
MSNBC· 2025-09-29 17:34
National Security & Political Landscape - The Trump administration's plan to deploy National Guard troops to Portland, Oregon, faces legal challenges, with the state's attorney general arguing the president lacks the authority to federalize the National Guard [2][3] - The administration has previously deployed troops to Los Angeles and Washington DC and announced a planned deployment to Memphis, threatening similar actions in other Democratic-run cities [4] - The Justice Department is deploying agents to secure ICE buildings nationwide in response to recent incidents of political violence [5] - A rare gathering of senior military leaders from around the world is convened by the Secretary of Defense, with President Trump planning to attend [6] Military & Political Culture - Concerns exist regarding the impact of deploying National Guard troops for law enforcement duties on their readiness and morale, as they are not trained as law enforcement officers [9][10] - The military is traditionally apolitical and transitions to supporting new administrations, but the current administration's approach is seen as chaotic and potentially damaging to national security [18][19] - The Secretary of Defense's meeting with military leaders is viewed as unusual, with potential for misinterpretation of military culture and expectations of political displays [14][16][17] Immigration & Law Enforcement - The potential removal of 10 to 12 million primarily Latino workers could lead to significant conflict, suggesting local community policing and state police are better suited to address the issue than the National Guard [11][12]
Dr. Gupta reacts to Florida eliminating vaccine mandates
MSNBC· 2025-09-04 00:25
What are your thoughts today. >> This is just to be clear, this is a a performative political stunt and what we've seen and they've made this possible. Lapo and and and Dantis is nonmed exemptions in the state of Florida have only been increasing.So this is to do this really is just all performance. There's really no substance to it. But where the rubber meets the road is for families that don't want their children to be in unsafe environments.And you know, I think it's important to call out there is strong ...
'This is a political stunt': Military leaders sound off on Trump's National Guard deployment
MSNBC· 2025-08-12 20:59
Political & Legal Concerns - The report highlights concerns over the potential federalization of Washington DC's police force and the legality of such actions, raising questions about the implications of using the military on American soil [2] - The deployment of National Guard troops is questioned, particularly regarding their mission, task, and purpose, with some suggesting it's a political stunt for intimidation [11][12] - Concerns are raised about the potential violation of laws prohibiting the military from engaging in police actions in a civilian environment, unless an insurrection act is declared [14][15] Military & Civil Unrest - The report discusses a plan for a military reaction force of 600 troops on standby for deployment in instances of civil unrest, split into two groups of 300 stationed at military bases in Alabama and Arizona [3] - The report references past instances of military deployment on American soil, including 10,000 active duty troops to the southwest US border and 4,700 National Guard troops and Marines to Los Angeles [4] - The report mentions a suggestion by a former defense secretary to potentially shoot protesters, highlighting the extreme nature of some proposed responses to civil unrest [5] Expert Opinions & Warnings - The report cites warnings from former military leaders, including General John Kelly and Mark Esper, about the dangers of using the military against American citizens for political purposes [4] - Experts express concern that the American people are being conditioned to the president calling up the National Guard or military for domestic and political goals, which is seen as dangerous [5][6] - Military officials emphasize that the military is trained to defend the country on a battlefield far away, not to be turned on neighbors and friends in their own towns and cities [7]