Preemption doctrine
Search documents
Class Action Accuses UnitedHealthcare of Misleading Seniors Into Giving Up Medicare Benefits
GlobeNewswire News Roomยท 2025-07-28 13:00
Core Points - The article discusses a class action lawsuit against UnitedHealthcare, alleging predatory practices and Medicare Advantage fraud, highlighting the serious implications for vulnerable populations' access to healthcare [1][4] - The lawsuit claims that UnitedHealthcare misled seniors into abandoning their Original Medicare benefits for profit-driven Medicare Advantage plans, which the company refers to as "Medicare-Disadvantage" plans [1][4] - The case emphasizes the need for accountability and protection for seniors from deceptive marketing practices that could lead to loss of Medicare benefits [2][3] Summary by Sections Allegations and Legal Proceedings - The lawsuit, titled The Estate of Bibi Ahmad v. UnitedHealth Group Inc., was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, alleging systemic and predatory advertising practices by UnitedHealthcare [1] - The court dismissed the case on "preemption" grounds but acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations regarding access to healthcare for vulnerable populations [1][4] - The anticipated appeal to the Ninth Circuit aims to reinstate the case for further proceedings, focusing on whether federal CMS regulations exceeded congressional authorization post-Chevron [6] Impact on Seniors - The article highlights the case of a 96-year-old cancer patient, D.D., who was misled into giving up her Medicare benefits, resulting in delayed treatment and unpaid medical bills [5] - The lawsuit claims that UnitedHealthcare's misleading advertising affected hundreds of thousands of seniors nationwide, particularly in California [6] Corporate Practices and Financial Performance - UnitedHealthcare reported over $22.3 billion in profits in 2023, raising concerns about corporate greed and the impact of denied medical claims on seniors [3] - The lawsuit alleges that UnitedHealthcare's advertising misrepresented its Medicare Advantage plans as supplements to Original Medicare, which was not the case [4]