Workflow
probable cause
icon
Search documents
Jack Smith: 'Powerful evidence' in classified docs case against Trump
MSNBC· 2025-12-17 21:41
Investigation & Testimony - Jack Smith's testimony behind closed doors focused on toll data requested from Republican senators regarding interactions with the White House around January 6, 2021 [2] - Democratic members felt confident Smith was handling himself well, noting a disparity between his capacity to answer questions and Republican staff members' capacity to ask them [4] - Jack Smith wanted the deposition to be public, but Jim Jordan had concerns about giving Smith a platform against President Trump [5][6] Political Implications - Republicans are accused of projecting Jack Smith as a political animal while simultaneously preventing him from publicly presenting his investigation's findings [7] - A closed session for Jack Smith raises concerns that his statements will be cherry-picked and used to rewrite history [11][12] - Republicans question whether the special counsel had probable cause for the search warrant at Mara Lago [16] - Republicans may face challenges in demonstrating a lack of probable cause due to restrictions on Smith's ability to disclose evidence [17] Evidence & Disagreements - Evidence against Donald Trump includes video surveillance and text messages related to moving classified records [12][13] - Internal disagreement existed within the Justice Department and FBI regarding the propriety of executing the search warrant on Mara Lago [20] - FBI officials agreed on probable cause after obtaining surveillance tape from Mara Lago, a fact Republicans allegedly omitted [23][24] - A judge signed off on probable cause on August 5th, and the FBI raid on August 8th resulted in the collection of hundreds of pages of top-secret records [25] Future Implications - If Democrats regain control, Jack Smith is likely to testify publicly [26] - The current investigation could open the door for Democrats to investigate Republican figures in the future [27]
Key Takeaways From NY AG Letitia James DOJ Indictment
Bloomberg Television· 2025-10-09 22:29
Legal & Political Analysis - The analysis draws parallels between the situation and the James Comey case, suggesting potential weaponization of prosecutorial decisions by the president [1][2] - Concerns are raised about the lack of probable cause in the indictments and the ethical implications for the prosecutors involved [2] - The president's public statements are seen as influencing the prosecution, raising questions about conflicts of interest [3][4][5] - Senator Schiff suggests the Justice Department is being used to target political enemies [6][7] - The analysis suggests potential legal action against Donald Trump after leaving office, including possible impeachment articles [10] Separation of Powers & Federalism - The situation implicates separation of powers and federalism issues, particularly concerning the prosecution of political opponents [8][9] - The analysis questions whether prosecuting enemies is an official duty of the president, potentially negating presidential immunity [9] - Pam Bondi's duty as Attorney General is to the Constitution, not to the President [10][11]
FBI and DOJ being 'politicized' in way 'we've never seen in modern history'
MSNBC· 2025-08-22 20:45
Investigation Focus - The FBI searched John Bolton's home for over 7 hours, seeking evidence related to the possession and potential leaking of sensitive national defense or classified information [2][11] - The investigation is focused on the last four years, potentially circumventing statute of limitations concerns related to Bolton's book [11] - A magistrate judge authorized the search, indicating probable cause of a crime [4] Political Context & Concerns - The search occurs amidst concerns about the politicization of the FBI and Justice Department [3] - The Vice President's comments, using "we" to describe the Justice Department, raised questions about White House influence [9][10] - Trump's past criticisms of Bolton and vows of retribution, coupled with the coincidences surrounding the investigation, raise credibility concerns [25][26] Information Disclosure & Transparency - Calls are being made for the release of the affidavit used to justify the search, similar to the transparency following the Mar-a-Lago search [13] - The White House's knowledge and involvement in the investigation are being questioned, particularly given conflicting statements from Trump and JD Vance [18][19] Potential Motivations & Implications - The possibility that Bolton, a critic of Trump's handling of classified information, is now under investigation for similar offenses is noted [24][25] - Concerns are raised that the investigation could be politically motivated, potentially undermining the presumption of good faith [26][28]