Workflow
unlawful orders
icon
Search documents
'Consequences for abject war crimes': Hegseth in 2016 takes a very different tone on unlawful orders
MSNBC· 2025-12-03 11:51
Personnel & Political Analysis - Pete Hexith's position within the White House is precarious, facing unpopularity and a lack of respect, potentially impacting his future [1] - The administration's reaction to Hexith's past statements and actions is influenced by a desire to avoid repeating past mistakes, leading to a potential digging-in stance [12] - A potential breach in relations between civilian leadership and the military could arise due to disagreements over lawful orders, especially in domestic situations [12][13] - The handling of the immediate incident involving Hexith could significantly affect future relations between the military and civilian leadership [14] Ethical & Legal Considerations - The discussion revolves around the consequences for "abject war crimes" and the military's duty to refuse unlawful orders [1][2][3][4][15] - Hexith's 2016 statement emphasized the need for consequences for unlawful and ruthless actions, aligning with the military's ethos [1][2][3][4][15] - Concerns are raised about potential reckless or irresponsible actions endangering military personnel during missions [9][10] Incident Analysis - The report mentions "Singlegate," an incident involving Pete Hexith allegedly revealing classified plans on a public app, leading to an Inspector General investigation [8][9][10] - The incident involved the potential exposure of classified war plans, including details about troop deployments, via a publicly available app [9]
Rep. Moulton addresses Hegseth unlawful orders
MSNBC· 2025-12-01 02:35
We begin this hour with new allegations that President Trump is expanding his retribution campaign beyond the Justice Department. A new report alleges Defense Secretary Pete Hgsith is using the Pentagon to wage retaliation on Trump's behalf. According to the Washington Post, a retired Army general speaking on the condition of anonymity out of fear for retaliation says after Trump won re-election, he made a list of the ways he could be attacked again.He came up with three possibilities. Civil lawsuit, IRS au ...
‘Unbelievably incompetent’: Dem blasts Trump admin leadership amid Ukraine-Russia peace talks
MSNBC· 2025-11-26 03:02
US Foreign Policy & National Security Concerns - The report suggests potential incompetence within the administration, questioning the sidelining of Secretary of Defense Hegathth and the role of less experienced individuals in major peace negotiations [1][2] - Concerns are raised about Steve Wickoff's interactions with Russian officials regarding a potential Ukraine-Russia deal, with accusations that he is being "bamboozled" by the Russians, potentially leading to a peace plan that favors Russian interests [3][6] - Secretary of State Marco Rubio is accused of dishonesty and untrustworthiness, further complicating the negotiation process [5] - The report highlights concerns about potential unlawful orders within the military and the Secretary of Defense's handling of classified information, raising questions about his competence and adherence to regulations [7][8][9] Congressional Oversight & Executive Power - A Congressman is introducing legislation to prevent unauthorized military action in Venezuela, aiming to restrict the executive branch from using federal funds for military intervention without congressional approval [11][12] - The Congressman draws a parallel to the Iraq War, emphasizing the importance of congressional authorization for military force [12][13] - The report acknowledges the limitations of the minority party in Congress to check the administration's actions but emphasizes the importance of engaging with Republican colleagues to address concerns about foreign policy decisions [15][16][17]
NEW: FBI reached out to Capitol police to arrange interviews with Dems in video to troops
MSNBC· 2025-11-25 18:52
Investigation & Legal Aspects - FBI is scheduling interviews with six senators through the Capitol Police, though it doesn't necessarily indicate an ongoing investigation [1][2] - Speech and debate clause protects members of Congress from prosecution for actions connected to their legislative duties [3] - A review is being launched to determine if the video falls under the articles of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), potentially restricting service member speech [6] - The UCMJ applies to retirees, raising questions about threatening a sitting senator with court martial under UCMJ provisions [6][7] - The Pentagon's statement refers to federal laws prohibiting actions interfering with the loyalty, morale, or good order of the armed forces [8] - A 1948 Cold War era statute, 18USC 2387, attempts to criminalize actions intended to interfere with the loyalty of those in service, potentially conflicting with the 1969 Brandenburgg case [9] Military Duty & Orders - Military members have a legal duty to follow all lawful orders, presumed to be lawful, but also a legal duty to disobey unlawful orders [12][13] - Disobeying an order carries the peril of court martial for disobedience, a military-unique crime [13] - Unlawful orders are those known to be unlawful or manifestly illegal, such as ordering a crime [14] - The senator's video failed to provide nuance regarding military members' catch-22 situation when facing potentially unlawful orders [15] - Illegality of an order is a complete defense, but the process involves facing potential court martial or adverse administrative action [16]