Nicolet Bankshares (NYSE:NIC) Earnings Call Presentation

Transaction Overview - Nicolet will acquire MidWestOne in a 100% stock transaction with a fixed exchange ratio of 03175x Nicolet shares for each MidWestOne share[13] - The aggregate consideration is valued at $8641 million, or $4137 per MidWestOne share, representing a 452% market premium[13] - Pro forma ownership will be approximately 691% for Nicolet and 309% for MidWestOne[13] Financial Impact - The transaction is expected to be ~37% accretive to Nicolet's fully-phased 2026E GAAP EPS[9] - Nicolet anticipates a fully-phased 2026E ROATCE of ~23%[9] - The pro forma CET1 ratio at closing is projected to be 106%, requiring no additional capital to support the transaction[9] - The transaction is expected to result in approximately 1% tangible book value per share dilution, with a very short earnback period of ~01 year[9, 25] Strategic Rationale - The acquisition will create a ~$15 billion+ asset bank, enhancing scale and positioning the company for significant growth across the Upper Midwest region[9] - The combined company is expected to enhance existing top quartile/decile financial operating metrics versus peers[9] - Nicolet will immediately solidify its position as a top 5 bank by deposit market share across the state of Iowa and accelerates growth trajectory in Minneapolis-St Paul MSA by adding $1 billion+ of deposits to existing network[9] - The acquisition adds ~$34 billion+ of wealth management AUA across new markets, resulting in $9 billion+ AUA for the combined company[9] Pro Forma Financials - At closing, the pro forma company is expected to have $157 billion in total assets, $113 billion in total loans, $133 billion in total deposits, and $28 billion in market capitalization[12]