Core Viewpoint - The article emphasizes the importance of a multi-dimensional technology assessment framework for evaluating the applicability of technology in cultural projects, focusing on cultural preservation and innovation [1][2]. Group 1: Multi-Dimensional Assessment Framework - The framework consists of five core dimensions: cultural value, user experience, technical feasibility, economic sustainability, and social impact [3][4][5]. - Cultural value dimension assesses whether technology enhances cultural expression without altering its essence, particularly in areas like intangible cultural heritage [3]. - User experience dimension focuses on the seamless integration of technology into cultural narratives to enhance emotional engagement [3]. - Technical feasibility dimension evaluates the maturity, usability, and long-term stability of the technology [4]. - Economic sustainability dimension analyzes cost-effectiveness, market potential, and scalability of the technology [4]. - Social impact dimension considers the alignment of technology with cultural policies and its broader societal implications [5]. Group 2: Success and Failure Analysis - Successful technology applications balance all five dimensions, while failures often stem from significant issues in one or more dimensions [6]. - Examples illustrate that technologies like VR can fail if they do not authentically represent cultural nuances, leading to a distorted understanding of cultural heritage [6][7]. Group 3: Practical Six-Step Evaluation Framework - The six-step framework includes: 1. Demand analysis to identify core problems and audience needs [8]. 2. Cultural adaptability assessment to ensure technology accurately expresses cultural essence [8]. 3. User experience testing through prototypes and feedback [8]. 4. Technical feasibility analysis to evaluate maturity and maintenance [9]. 5. Economic sustainability assessment focusing on ROI and operational costs [10]. 6. Social impact evaluation regarding compliance with cultural policies [11]. Group 4: Strategies to Avoid Common Pitfalls - Key strategies include prioritizing cultural values over technology, conducting small-scale trials for iterative improvements, fostering cross-disciplinary collaboration, establishing user feedback mechanisms, and focusing on long-term cultural and social benefits rather than short-term trends [13][14][15][16][17]. Group 5: Conclusion - The integration of technology and culture requires a thoughtful dialogue that respects cultural integrity while leveraging technological advancements to enhance cultural vitality [18].
文化科技融合评估框架：如何判断一个技术是否真正适合应用到文化项目？
3 6 Ke·2025-05-14 00:31